It has been used in various fields, including health care, finance, education, transportation, and has been well documented in both operations research and economics literature shim, 2003. Measuring the efficiency of decision making units the university of. The beginnings of dea were with edwardo rhodess dissertation work at carnegie mellon university, under the supervision of w. Fdh model allows the free disposability to construct the production possiblity set. Charnes, cooper, and rhodes 1978 developed the ccrcharnescooperrhdes model to evaluate the production units ef. Cooper graduate school of business administration, harvard university, cambridge ma, u. European journal of operational research 2 1978429444. Apart from the standard fare consisting of the basic input and outputoriented dea models formulated by charnes, cooper, and rhodes, and banker, charnes, and cooper, the book covers developments such as the directional distance function, free disposal.
The ccr model was developed by charnes cooper and rhodes 1978. Data envelopment analysis for operational efficiency. In the subsequent literature the development of research leading up to this paper tended to. Banker, charnes and cooper 1984 subsequently intro duced the bcc model which separates technical efficiency and scale efficiency. Thereby, the problem is converted to an interval programming. A note on returns to scale in dea temple university. Science and education publishing is an academic publisher of open access journals. In this paper, a fuzzy version of ccr model charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978 with asymmetrical triangular fuzzy number is presented and a procedure is suggested for its solution. Thus, by using linear programming and by applying nonparametric techniques of frontier estimation, the efficiency of a dmu.
Read a twostage dea model considering shared inputs and free intermediate measures, expert systems with applications on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Performance evaluation of the public libraries in usa using. Envelopment analysis dea was originated by charnes, cooper, and rhodes 1978. Rather, they are based on nonparametrically enveloping a given sample of data with a piecewise linear hull. Evaluated units which has common inputs and outputs is called decision making units dmu. Data of 19 coalfired steamelectric generating plants operating in illinois in 1978. Charnes, cooper, and rhodes 1978 developed the ccrcharnescooperrhdes model to evaluate the. The stata journal free disposal hullfdh analysis for e. Due to the interdisciplinary nature of much of the research, there is a need for a single source referencing the wide range of articles appearing in the literature.
The study applies charnes, cooper and rhodes ccr model 1978 of data envelopment analysis dea and the banker, charnes and cooper bcc model 1984. The faculty was full of hope, but bill outshone all of us in couragethe least willing to go slowly and hesitantly, and to compromise with conventional wisdom and superstition. In this paper we contrast the dea and activity analysis approaches by charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978 and shephard 1970, respectively. Measuring technical progress with data envelopment analysis. Ranking police administration units on the basis of crime. Banker is a professor at temple university and robert s. Rhodes state university of new york at buffalo, albany ny, b.
A model for measuring the efficiency of decision making units dmus is presented, along with related methods of implementation and interpretation. Cooper, seiford and tone 2006 provided an indepth coverage of various dea models. In encyclopedia of business analytics and optimization. The measurement of relative efficiency where there are multiple possibly incommensurate inputs and outputs was addressed by farrell and developed by farrell and fieldhouse2, focusing on the construction of a hypothetical efficient unit, as a weighted average of efficient units, to act as a comparator for an inefficient unit. The origin of this book was a conference on new uses of dea in 2 management and public policy which was held at the ic institute of the university of texas at austin on september 2729, 1989. A nonlinear nonconvex programming model provides a new definition of efficiency for use in evaluating activities of notforprofit entities participating in public programs. In recent years there has been an exponential growth in the number of publications related to theory and applications of data envelopment analysis dea. Equivalence and implementation of alternative methods for. A bibliography for data envelopment analysis 19781996. Charnes a cooper w w rhodes e 1978 measuring the efficiency. Gsia was, from the outset, dedicated to erecting business education on a foundation of basic analytic tools and social science knowledge. Apart from the standard fare consisting of the basic input and outputoriented dea models formulated by charnes, cooper, and rhodes, and banker, charnes, and cooper, the book covers developments such as the directional distance function, free disposal hull fdh analysis, nonradial measures of efficiency, multiplier bounds, mergers and break. Tutorial ali emrouznejads data envelopment analysis. In the case of measuring the efficiency of higher education institutions, the commonly.
International journal of business and economic sciences. In the dea methodology, formally developed by charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978, efficiency is defined as a ratio of weighted sum of outputs to a weighted sum of inputs, where the weights structure is calculated by means of mathematical programming and constant returns to scale crs are assumed. We show that by appropriately normalizing shephards output price model the two approaches coincide. Performance evaluation of the public libraries in usa using data envelopment analysis. Kaplan is a professor emeritus at harvard university. His most celebrated publication is a 1978 paper with abraham charnes and edwardo l. Many of these extensions and the underlying models were originally proposed to overcome difficulties associated with the data encountered in the course of a particular study see for example 3,4,5,9. A scalar measure of the efficiency of each participating. Dea, which was introduced by charnes, cooper, and rhodes as a mathematicsbased research method in 1978, allows measuring the relative efficiency of decisionmaking units dmu kuah, wong.
Free disposability means if a speci c pair of input and. Analysis and we present its application in information and communication. Analysis originated with the paper by charnes cooper and rhodes in 1978. In dea, multiple outputs and inputs are reduced into a single outputinput form in which efficiency measure is yielded after necessary calculations are completed with linear programming. This paper argues that for evaluating efficiency in the economic sense of an organization any dmu, in the charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978 terminology, the notion of frontier is less basic than the one of dominance. Efficiency analysis of nonlife insurance companies in. First presented in 1978 and based on the paper of farrell, the first dea model is known in the literature as the ccr model, after its authors, charnes, cooper and rhodes. With the help of these suggested models performance can be evaluated.
This is a method for evaluating decision making units within an organization, by using imputed shadow prices. Data envelopment analysis deathirty years on request pdf. Charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978 suggest that t he vectors u and v must be determined by the linear pro gramming pro blem lpp 2 at table 1, called ccr o r. Science and education publishing, publisher of open access journals in the scientific, technical and medical fields. View citations in econpapers 4733 track citations by rss feed. Rhodes, measuring the efficiency of decision making units, european j. Since the original dea study by charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978, there has been a rapid growth in the field. An application of data envelopment analysis to program follow through. Performance evaluation of the public libraries in usa. Rhodes is known for the invention of data envelopment analysis in 1978, as part of his doctoral dissertation, in the paper measuring the efficiency of decision making units with william w.
The application of dea in ict has received considerable attention in the recent. Recently, new dea models have been developed to assess sustainability issues. Since the original paper by charnes, cooper and rhodes 7 establishing data envelopment analysis dea, a number of theoretical extensions have appeared in the literature see seiford. Dea was initiated by charnes cooper and rhodes in 1978 in their seminal paper chames et al. New data envelopment analysis models for assessing. The ccr model was developed by charnes cooper and rhodes. These prices are computed using a fractional program that is solved by reducing it to a linear program. Read measuring technical progress with data envelopment analysis, european journal of operational research on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. This brief note adds computational convenience and efficiency to the article by banker and thrall on returns to scale in dea by modifying one of their suggestions to avoid the need for examining all. Read full text articles or submit your research for publishing. Banks under reference are treated as intermediaries between.
A scalar measure of the efficiency of each participating unit is thereby provided, along with methods for objectively. Cambridge core mathematical physics data envelopment analysis by subhash c. The data envelopment analysis dea is a popular operational research technique. Pdf financial performance and efficiency of cooperative. Measuring the efficiency of decision making units sciencedirect. We resort to relative rather than absolute efficiencies because in most practical contexts we lack sufficient information to derive the superior measures of absolute efficiency. In the past 26 years, more than 2000 articles on dea have been published in economics, sociology, strategy, marketing, and many other disciplines. Radial efficiency measures in data envelopment analysis. Dea technique was first developed by charnes, cooper, and rhodes in 1978. Charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978, 1981 in troduced the ccr model of data envelopment analysis dea to evaluate the relative efficiency of decision making units dmus. In this paper we focus on the application of dea in information and communication technologies. Charnes, cooper, and rhodes 1978 introduced dea as a tool for measuring efficiency and productivity of decision making units.
Banker, charnes and cooper 1984 subsequently intro duced the bcc model which separates technical efficiency and. Abstractsome 30 years ago charnes, cooper and rhodes a. This model was later followed up by banker, charnes and cooper 1984. The basic idea is to transform the fuzzy ccr model into a crisp linear programming problem by applying an alternative. A multistage methodology for the solution of orientated dea models. It has been used in various fields, including health care, finance, education, transportation, and has been well documented in. Center for efficiency and productivity analysis cepa working paper, no 198. Original dea model charnes, cooper rhodes, 19781 all inputs and outputs are nonnegative. Banks under reference are treated as intermediaries. On the origins of data envelopment analysis, journal of. Charnes a cooper w w rhodes e 1978 measuring the efficiency of decision making from business 101 at hanoi university of technology.
Free disposal hullfdh analysis for e ciency measurement. Efficiency analysis and ranking of dmus with fuzzy data. The ccr model was developed by charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978, where each decisionmaking unit dmu placed on efficiency border is efficient and units not placed on border are inefficient and the level of inefficiency is determined through the radial distance to the border. Later banker, charnes, and cooper 1984 introduced the variable returns to scale vrs e. It also publishes academic books and conference proceedings. Since the incept of charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978, dea has gained increasing popularity in theoretical and applied work.
This methodology treats multiple inputs and multiple outputs. Introduced by charnes, cooper and rhodes in 1978, the data envelopment analysis is an important branch of operations research, as well as of economics as evidenced by numerous publications with. Analysis and we present its application in information and communication technologies according to recently published studies in this area. A twostage dea model considering shared inputs and free. European journal of operational research, 1978, vol. The authors intention in maintaining a bibliography of dearelated articles is to provide such a single source and thus. Introduction to the theory and application of data. In the case of measuring the efficiency of higher education institutions, the commonly used inputs are expenditure on tertiary education. Dea is a nonparametric method and it was derived by charnes cooper rhodes in 1978 setting out farrells total factor productivity approach with linear programming based. Charnes, cooper, and rhodes 1978 provided the original dea constant returns to scale crs model, later extended to variable returns to scale vrs by banker charnes, and cooper 1984. Since the incept of charnes, cooper and rhodes 1978, dea has gained increasing.
1507 807 941 20 849 394 128 983 265 889 1061 298 1170 475 1218 1294 780 1411 661 482 93 1220 1228 1034 756 843 866 777 350 1320 1123 194 1431 76 419 68 474 639